Invite a reset
Say what you’re seeing. “We’ve heard the same two options a few times. Could we take 13 minutes to see what is keeping us from choosing?” Ask whether someone who has to make the decision is missing. If they are, use the time to agree on what to ask them.
Run four short rounds
- Write before speaking · 2 min
Everyone writes one observation and one concern. Read them to yourself before sharing.
- Hear the room · 4 min
Take one turn each. Ask someone to paraphrase the concern before anyone answers it.
- Name the disagreement · 3 min
Which fact, value, or tradeoff would make these two views lead to different choices?
- Decide what to try · 4 min
Agree on one small action. Choose who will run it, when to review it, and what you will look for.
The quiet writing round gives people a chance to think before the first answer sets the direction. You can ask people to pass and come back to them. See Liberating Structures’ 1-2-4-All for a longer approach with pairs and small groups.
Record what the group actually agreed to
If people are still missing important information, choose Get information first. Record the person who will get it, the next review time, and what evidence would help. Read the handoff aloud before copying it.